| 1. Jeff Waskiewicz | Greg Vaughn | Vinny Castilla | Gary Sheffield |
| 2. Michael "Kitt" McKnight | Troy Percival | John Wetteland | |
| 3. Sam Donaldson | Craig Biggio | Shannon Stewart | |
| 4. Matt Plante | None | ||
| 5. Ken Daniels | Tom Gordon | Jeff Shaw | |
| 6. Rich DeSalvo | Pedro Martinez | Albert Belle | Kenny Lofton |
| 7. Eric Cohen | Greg Maddux | Mariano Rivera | |
| 8. "Uncle" Tony Warburton | None | ||
| 9. John Tietz | Nomar Garciaparra | Rickey Henderson | David Segui |
| 10. Mike "J." Smith | Barry Bonds | Mo Vaughn | Frank Thomas |
| 11. Mark "Wanker" Schwanekamp | Dante Bichette | Chipper Jones | Jeff Kent |
| 12. Mike "Nick" Nichols | Mark McGwire | Trevor Hoffman | |
| 13. Dan Joseph | Rod Beck | Curt Schilling | Larry Walker |
| 14. Eric "EJ" John | None | ||
| 15. Bob Cimini | Sammy Sosa | Mike Piazza | |
| 16. Dave "Fribble" Fribourg | Mike Jackson | Randy Johnson | |
| 17. Keith Carangelo | None | ||
| 18. David Harris | Alex Rodriguez | Vladimir Guerrero | Jeff Montgomery |
| 19. John "Duck" Niccoli | Ugueth Urbina | ||
| 20. Fritz Strydom | Ken Griffey Jr | John Smoltz | Manny Ramirez |
Cohen 7th 1999 Fribble 08/10 10th 1999 Cohen Fribble Harris 13th 1999 Smith 05/25 15th 1999 Harris Smith Duck 9th 1999 Kitt 04/04 17th 1999 Duck Kitt Duck 04/04 Troy Percival Kitt Sam 14th 1999 Smith 08/31 5th 1999 Sam Smith Sam 6th 1999 Smith 04/04 12th 1999 Sam Smith Sam 04/04 Mo Vaughn Smith Smith 8th 1999 Keith 04/04 5th 1999 Smith Keith Smith Frank Thomas 04/04 Keith